Ethics and AI

There are numerous ethical considerations when using AI tools and generating new content. Who owns the output, especially if it’s heavily influenced by or directly copied from copyrighted material? How do we think about human bias when it comes to the data analyzed by large language models (LLMs)?

As web practitioners, it’s critical that we build new technology thoughtfully and responsibly. There are numerous efforts across the world to answer these questions (and more). We cannot cover every concern, but we can open a dialogue for how you think about ethics when using AI.

Here are some key areas to consider when using and building with AI tools:

• Content ownership and copyright. Copyright is a legal protection for
  original works of authorship. The law differs from country-to-country, and many
  countries are debating what happens with content generated by AI.
  Whenever you publish content, you should know the answer to the following
  question: Are you infringing on someone else’s copyrighted content? This can
  be harder than you may expect to answer!
• Bias and discrimination. Computers and algorithms are built by humans,
  trained on data that may be collected by humans, and thus are subject to human
  bias and harmful stereotypes. This directly impacts the output.
• Privacy and security. This is important for all web sites and web
  applications, but especially when there is sensitive or personally
  identifiable information. Exposing user data to more third-parties with cloud
  APIs is a concern. It’s important that any data transmission is secure and
  continuously monitored.

Google’s AI principles

We are committed to developing technology responsibly and establishing specific
areas of AI we won’t pursue. In fact, Google has committed to several
AI principles, with a
central team
focused on governance and implementation.

In short, our objectives for AI applications are as follows:

1. Be socially beneficial.
2. Avoid creating or reinforcing unfair bias.
3. Be built and tested for safety.
4. Be accountable to people.
5. Incorporate privacy design principles.
6. Uphold high standards of scientific excellence.
7. Be made available for uses that accord with these principles.

While we as web developers may not always be responsible for creating the models
and collecting the datasets which train AI tools, we are responsible for what
tools we use and what end-products we create with AI.

Organizations across the web thinking about ethics

There are a number of nonprofits, non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and
other companies that have centered their work and research into creating
ethical AI.

Here are just a few examples.

• ForHumanity
• Center for AI and Digital Policy
• W3C working group
• Authorship and AI tools | COPE: Committee on Publication Ethics

There’s much more work to do in this space, and many more considerations yet to
discover. We intend to be intentional with ethical considerations for every
piece of content we generate.